Surrounded by mangrove islands on the eastern shore of Charlotte Harbor, Pirate Harbor is one of the Southwest Florida's best kept secrets. The neighborhoods of Pirate Harbor beautifully conform to canal formations that allow boaters to quickly access Charlotte Harbor for fishing and recreation. From Charlotte Harbor, boaters can access Burnt Store Marina, Bokeelia, Turtle Bay, Fisherman's Village on the Peace River, state parks and the areas pristine beaches. ... more. Homes in Pirate Harbor range from Florida ranch, Key West to modern contemporary styled homes. For those wanting to build new, you are in luck as this Punta Gorda community has several waterfront parcels available for new homes. Most properties are canal front, offering private dockage and boat lifts to take full advantage of the natural canal system.